In the podcasting world, true crime is one of the most popular categories. But this genre is about more than unsolved murders and cat-and-mouse games—it’s real life and it’s fascinating.
The following podcasts provide more than just entertainment. Each episode is a journey into a real life event that could give you ideas for your own podcast. From unsolved murders and cold cases to deep dives into the mind’s of the most notorious killers, these are sure to make you think and keep you hooked.
Best True Crime Podcasts
Whether you're new to true crime or you've been following these stories for a while, this list is for you. And if you're a podcaster, get ready to be inspired. The best true crime podcasts show just how powerful and engaging real-life stories can be.
#1. My Favorite Murder
Hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark, My Favorite Murder is an engaging combination of true crime and comedy, which adds a layer of levity to the dark subject matter.
My Favorite Murder has cultivated a dedicated fan base known as “Murderinos”, making it a staple for those who like their crime stories with a side of humor and human connection.
#2. Crime Junkie
Hosted by Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat, Crime Junkie is a riveting podcast that has quickly become a favorite among true crime enthusiasts. This weekly show delves into a variety of cases, ranging from well-known murders to obscure missing persons cases.
The podcast stands out for its compelling storytelling, meticulous research, and the hosts' ability to bring these cases to life. Ashley and Brit not only recount the facts of each case but also bring a sense of empathy and awareness to the victims' stories. Their passionate and engaging delivery has garnered a loyal following, making Crime Junkie a must-listen for anyone fascinated by the complexities and mysteries of true crime.
#3. The Deck
The “deck” in this podcast’s name refers to cold case cards—decks of playing cards that feature information related to unsolved criminal cases, distributed in prisons and to the public to generate tips and leads. Hosted by Crime Junkie’s Ashley Flowers, the podcast delves deeply into each case, offering detailed narratives, background information, and potential theories.
What makes "The Deck" particularly impactful is its commitment to shining a light on lesser-known cases and giving a voice to the forgotten or overlooked victims of these unsolved crimes.
#4. Dr. Death
Focusing on the dark side of the medical profession, this podcast series has been brought to life through meticulous investigative reporting. Hosted by Laura Beil, season one follows the story of Dr. Christopher Duntsch, a neurosurgeon whose career was marred by a disturbing pattern of patient harm.
The podcast meticulously uncovers the chilling details of how Duntsch's actions led to devastating consequences for his patients (despite numerous red flags).
Dr. Death is not just a true crime story; it's a sobering look at trust, ethics, and accountability in healthcare, making it a must-listen for those interested in medical dramas and real-life horror stories of professional malpractice.
#5. Anatomy of Murder
Co-hosted by a former New York City homicide prosecutor and a veteran crime journalist, this podcast lends an expert eye to the investigative and legal proceedings tied to each case.
Each episode navigates through the complexities of a case, from the discovery of the crime to the courtroom battles, offering insights into the minds of the perpetrators and the experiences of the victims and their families.
Anatomy of Murder is a compelling listen for those interested in the finer details of crime solving and the justice system.
#6. Bone Valley
In 1987, 18-year-old Michelle Schofield was murdered. Two years later, her husband Leo was convicted of the crime and sentenced to life in prison. But what seemed like an open-and-shut case was busted wide open when new evidence—and a confession—came from another source.
Leo Schofield maintains his innocence yet remains behind bars. Hosted by investigative journalist Gilbert King, Bone Valley takes listeners on a detailed journey through the case, exploring every facet of the evidence to point law enforcement in a new direction.
Bone Valley is not just a narrative of a cold case; it's a poignant exploration of loss, perseverance, and the relentless pursuit of justice, making it a compelling listen for fans of true crime and unsolved mysteries.
#7. The Dropout
True crime is often synonymous with “murder,” but real-life crimes can be a lot more varied.
The Dropout tells the compelling story of the rise and fall of Elizabeth Holmes—once hailed as a revolutionary entrepreneur in the healthcare technology industry. Holmes, however, turned out to be one of the biggest frauds in Silicon Valley.
This award-winning podcast delves into the complex personality of Holmes, the deceptive practices at Theranos, and the broader implications of the scandal for the tech and healthcare sectors. It's a story of ambition, deception, and the perils of the “fake it till you make it” culture in the startup world.
#8. Morbid
Known for its unique blend of humor and detailed case analysis, Morbid offers a fresh and engaging perspective on a wide range of topics within the true crime genre.
From the most notorious serial killers to eerie unsolved mysteries, each episode combines thorough research with light-hearted, often comedic, commentary. This approach makes Morbid stand out in the true crime podcast landscape, as it caters to listeners who appreciate a balance of respectful storytelling and relatable banter.
The hosts' chemistry and approachable style have garnered a dedicated following, making Morbid a go-to podcast for those who enjoy a more conversational and entertaining take on true crime stories.
#9. The Shrink Next Door
This intriguing podcast delves into the bizarre relationship between a psychiatrist, Dr. Isaac Herschkopf, and his long-term patient, Martin Markowitz. The podcast, hosted by a veteran journalist who was neighbors with the duo, unravels a complex tale of manipulation, control, and boundary-crossing.
Spanning over three decades, the story reveals how Dr. Herschkopf insinuated himself into every aspect of Markowitz’s life, including moving into his home and taking over his family business.
The Shrink Next Door is a compelling narrative that raises serious questions about trust and abuse of power in professional relationships, making it a fascinating listen for those interested in psychology, ethics, and human behavior.
#10. Bear Brook
Hosted by journalist Jason Moon, Bear Brook delves into the discovery of four unidentified bodies found 15 years apart in Bear Brook State Park in New Hampshire.
The podcast meticulously follows the twists and turns of the investigation, showcasing advancements in forensic science, particularly genetic genealogy, which played a crucial role in identifying the victims and eventually leading to the identification of the killer.
Weaving together interviews, police reports, and first-hand accounts, Bear Brook creates a compelling tapestry of storytelling that captures the essence of a true crime thriller. The podcast's thoughtful approach to such a complex and emotional case has made it a standout in the true crime genre, appealing to listeners who are interested in the intersection of science, detective work, and storytelling.
Conclusion
The world of true crime podcasts offers an array of captivating, thought-provoking, and often chilling stories that delve deep into the mysteries of human behavior and the complexities of the justice system.
Whether you're a long-time true crime aficionado or a newcomer to the genre, these podcasts promise to engage, challenge, and perhaps even change the way you view the world around you.
If you love podcasts (and we know you do), then you may want to check out some of these categories:
Top 20 Most Popular Story Podcasts
Top 10 Business Podcasts
Best Marketing Podcasts
Best Interview Podcasts
